The 2025 NCAA Division I men’s lacrosse season is already proving to be one of the most exciting in recent years. While some teams are living up to expectations, others are surprising fans with big wins, unexpected losses, and standout individual performances. With several weeks of action behind us, let's break down the biggest shocks and sure things of the season so far.
Sure Things: The Powerhouses Staying Strong
Syracuse’s Offense is the Real Deal
Syracuse entered this season with high expectations, and so far, they’ve delivered. Their offensive firepower has been on full display, and their ability to execute under pressure has made them one of the most dangerous teams in the country. One of the best examples of their grit came in a huge win against Johns Hopkins. Trailing by four goals in the fourth quarter, Syracuse pulled off a dramatic comeback to win 14-13.
One of the highlights of that game was a hidden-ball trick play that completely fooled the Hopkins defense, leading to a crucial goal. This kind of creativity, combined with their ability to finish strong, makes them a real threat as the season goes on. Their attack unit, led by star players like Joey Spallina, continues to prove why they were ranked among the best in the country. If they keep playing like this, they’ll be a serious contender for the national championship. This begs the age-old question, is ‘Cuse back?
Cornell is Calm, Collected, and Dangerous
Cornell has looked solid to start the season, showing a level of discipline and poise that makes them a tough team to beat. One of their standout moments came in a hard-fought win over Richmond, where their defense held strong and their offense capitalized on key opportunities. A true test to their teams poise in moments where the game may seem out of hand.
A big storyline in that game was Walker Wallace’s homecoming. The Cornell defender grew up in Richmond, and playing back in his hometown made the win even more special. He put on an impressive performance, helping Cornell shut down Richmond’s attack. The Big Red aren’t flashy, but they are consistent and fundamental, which is exactly what makes them a serious contender.
Shocks: The Surprises Shaking Up the Season
Ohio State Stuns Notre Dame
One of the biggest upsets of the season so far came when Ohio State took down Notre Dame 10-9 in a game that went right down to the wire. The Buckeyes were not expected to beat the reigning national champions, but they proved they are not a team to overlook.
The game-winning moment came from Jack O’Leary, who scored a dramatic last-second goal to seal the win for Ohio State. Their defense also deserves a lot of credit for keeping Notre Dame’s high-powered offense in check. This win immediately puts Ohio State in the conversation as a team that can make a deep postseason run.
Harvard’s Offense is Heating Up
Harvard has been on the rise early this season, and a lot of that has to do with Sam King. He has stepped up in a big way, leading the Crimson attack and putting up impressive numbers. His ability to make plays, both as a scorer and a passer, has given Harvard an edge in some key games.
They still have a lot to prove, but their offense has shown flashes of being one of the best in the country. If they can continue to build momentum, they could be a dark horse in the postseason.
Princeton’s Brick Wall Defense
Princeton has been making a statement on the defensive side of the ball, thanks in large part to goalie Michael Croddick. He has been shutting down some of the best offenses in the country, making huge saves and giving Princeton a real chance to win in every game they play.
In a season where a lot of teams are focusing on fast-paced offense, Princeton is proving that defense still wins games. If Croddick keeps playing at this level, they could become one of the toughest teams to beat when the tournament rolls around.
UMass, Fairfield, and Colgate: Underdogs Making Noise
This season isn’t just about the top teams. Some programs that weren’t expected to make headlines are suddenly turning heads with statement wins and strong performances.
UMass: Tough, Gritty, and Not Backing Down
UMass is showing they are not a team to overlook. They’ve pulled off some gritty wins and are proving to be one of the toughest defensive teams in the country. Their ability to frustrate opponents and control the tempo makes them a dangerous matchup for anyone.
They may not be in the national championship conversation yet, but if they keep playing like this, they will be a major problem for ranked teams.
Fairfield: One of the Biggest Surprise Teams of the Year
Fairfield has come out of nowhere and is starting to look like a team that could shock people in conference play.
Their offense has been efficient, and their defense is doing just enough to keep them in games. If they continue improving, they could be one of the biggest sleeper teams in the country.
Colgate: Ready to Make a Statement
Colgate has had an up-and-down start, but they are showing flashes of being a team on the rise. They have some young talent stepping up, and if they can put it all together, they could become a tough opponent by the end of the season.
For now, they are still a team that’s trying to prove themselves, but don’t be surprised if they pull off a big upset soon. Or... make it all the way to Memorial Day weekend.
Looking Ahead
With so many teams stepping up and surprising fans, the rest of the season is shaping up to be full of even more unexpected upsets and breakout performances. Will Syracuse keep their momentum? Can Ohio State prove their win over Notre Dame wasn’t a fluke? Will Harvard and Princeton continue their rise?
One thing is for sure—this season has been anything but predictable. As we move deeper into the schedule, expect more drama, more last-second goals, and more teams proving that anything can happen in the greatest sport on earth.